Apple ML ★ 92 4 min

RISED: Rubrics for Agentic Multi-Environment Selection and Self-Distillation

🔗 https://machinelearning.apple.com/research/rised-multi-environment-selection

📌 Apple ML 新研究:用 Rubric 取代純 Reward,訓練跨環境通用 Agent

TL;DR:RISED 用文字 rubric 取代純量 reward,解決多環境 RL 訓練中資料選擇與同質失敗批次的難題。

🎣 當一個 LLM agent 要同時在多種互動環境裡學習時,單純用一個數字當 reward,往往會漏掉很多重要資訊,比如這一批 rollout 到底「輸在哪裡」「贏在哪裡」。Apple ML 的這篇研究,試圖用文字取代數字,重新設計訓練資料的篩選方式。

🤔 多環境強化學習的兩個卡點

論文指出,把單一 LLM agent 跨多種互動環境聯合訓練,是通往「通用型 agent」的一條重要路徑,但現有的課程設計(curriculum)與資料選擇策略通常是以環境為單位分配訓練資源,或只依賴局部的 reward 訊號,並沒有明確考量「目前這一批不同環境的 rollout 之間」彼此的關係來做提示組(prompt-group)選擇。

同時,由於各環境的學習速度不一致,同一個訓練批次裡可能同時出現「全部失敗」和「全部成功」的 rollout 群組,而這類資料完全沒有組內相對 reward 訊號可用。這兩個問題共同指出:只靠純量 reward,在多環境 RL 裡既缺乏跨環境關係資訊,組內獎勵相同時也沒有對比訊號。這正是論文想引入更豐富的文字回饋(例如描述 rollout 行為的 rubric)來補足的地方。

🧩 RISED:rubric 同時拿來做資料選擇與策略監督

論文提出的 RISED 做法是:

  • 用一個 LLM judge,依照一套跨環境共用的預定義 rubric 詞彙表,為每一筆 rollout 打標籤,產生「行為剖面」(profile)。
  • 這些剖面被用來引導線上資料選擇,挑出與整個混合環境批次整體行為組成相符、同時跟已選資料重疊度較低的樣本。
  • 正向 rubric(描述理想行為)作為 on-policy self-distillation teacher 的特權上下文(privileged context),提供額外的 token 層級監督;
  • 負向 rubric(描述不理想行為)則用來引導後續 rollout 生成,避開反覆出現的失敗模式。

這三個元件組合起來就是 RISED:rubric 不只是拿來當 reward,而是同時驅動資料選擇與策略監督。

📊 跨多個模型骨幹都取得最高平均通過率

論文宣稱,在不同的模型骨幹(model backbones)上,RISED 都取得最高的平均通過率(mean pass rate),而且在每一個個別環境中的排名都是第一或第二。摘要並未提供具體的通過率數字或所比較的環境名單,因此本文不補上杜撰的數據。論文也提到可以透過 rubric 做進一步的行為變化分析,解釋這些提升從何而來。

🎯 實務啟示

如果你正在訓練需要跨多種工具/環境運作的 agent,這篇研究提供一個值得參考的方向:與其只盯著 reward 數字做課程編排,不如讓 LLM judge 用結構化的文字 rubric 去描述每次 rollout 的行為模式,再拿這些描述去驅動資料選擇與蒸餾式監督,可能比單純的 reward shaping 更能處理「組內信號缺失」的訓練死角。

🔗 來源

#ReinforcementLearning #LLMAgents #AppleML #RubricReward #SelfDistillation #MultiEnvironmentRL #DataSelection #AgenticAI #MachineLearning #CurriculumLearning

原始資料 Apple ML · 收集於 2026-10-07
來源原標題
RISED: Rubrics for Agentic Multi-Environment Selection and Self-Distillation
原始連結
https://machinelearning.apple.com/research/rised-multi-environment-selection

摘要原文

research area Data Science and Annotation , research area Speech and Natural Language Processing content type paper published October 2026 RISED: Rubrics for Agentic Multi-Environment Selection and Self-Distillation Authors Jingtan Wang†**, Sirajul Salekin, Young mok Jung, Javier Movellan, Bryan Kian Hsiang Low†, Manjot Bilkhu View publication Copy Bibtex Training a single LLM agent jointly across diverse interactive environments has attracted increasing attention as a route to generalist agents. Existing curriculum and data-selection strategies often allocate training at the environment level or prioritize local reward-based signals, without explicitly considering relationships between current rollouts across environments for prompt-group selection. Meanwhile, as environments are learned at different rates, all-failure and all-success rollout groups can coexist within a batch, leaving those data without group-relative reward signals. Both challenges highlight limitations of relying solely on scalar rewards in multi-environment RL: they provide limited information about cross-environment relationships and no within-group reward contrast when rewards are identical. This motivates richer textual feedback, such as rubrics describing rollout behaviours, to guide learning. Beyond rubrics’ usage as reward, we repurpose rubrics to guide both online data selection and policy supervision. An LLM judge tags each rollout using a predefined rubric vocabulary shared across environments. The resulting profiles guide the selection of data that aligns with the overall behavioural composition of the mixed-environment batch while limiting overlap with already-selected data. Available positive rubrics (describing desired behaviours) provide privileged context for an on-policy self-distillation teacher, supplying additional token-level supervision, while negative rubrics (describing undesired behaviours) guide subsequent rollout generation away from recurring failure modes. Together, these components form RISED. Across model backbones, RISED achieves the highest mean pass rate across environments and ranks first or second in every individual environment. Rubric-based analysis of RISED can further characterize the behavioural changes accompanying these gains. † National University of Singapore ** Work done while at Apple Related readings and updates. From Preferences to Principles: Rubric-Based Alignment for Grounded Knowledge Answers August 27, 2026 research area Methods and Algorithms , research area Speech and Natural Language Processing Designing effective reward signals for open-domain question answering is challenging because high-quality responses must simultaneously satisfy multiple aspects of answer quality that are difficult to capture with a holistic scalar objective. We introduce a rubric-based reward framework that generates query-specific rubrics grounded in retrieved evidence and decomposed into multiple quality dimensions, providing fine-grained supervision during… Read more RubiCap: Rubric-Guided Reinforcement Learning for Dense Image Captioning March 16, 2026 research area Computer Vision , research area Data Science and Annotation Dense image captioning is critical for cross-modal alignment in vision-language pretraining and text-to-image generation, but scaling expert-quality annotations is prohibitively expensive. While synthetic captioning via strong vision-language models (VLMs) is a practical alternative, supervised distillation often yields limited output diversity and weak generalization. Reinforcement learning (RL) could overcome these limitations, but its… Read more Discover opportunities in Machine Learning. Our research in machine learning breaks new ground every day. Work with us

由 claude-code/sonnet 自動生成